The age-old debate of renting versus buying a house is, in many ways, a reflection of one’s unique circumstances and priorities. It’s a decision that will shape your financial well-being, daily routine and sense of stability. As such, it’s a choice that merits careful consideration, in-depth analysis and a deep understanding of the implications involved.
Having trouble choosing between buying and renting? Check out our helpful guide to learn about some of the most important considerations.
Key Takeaways:
- The decision between buying and renting a home depends on your individual situation and preferences.
- Some of the most important factors to assess include the local housing market, your financial situation, your lifestyle and your long-term goals.
- Before making a decision, look closely at your financial situation. Affordability and rent-to-buy calculators can be helpful tools.
Renting Vs. Owning: Differences To Consider
Renting versus buying is an exciting but major decision. To help you choose between buying and renting, let’s examine some of the factors and questions to consider.
Monthly Payment
Many people believe buying a house is a better choice because a monthly mortgage payment is often less than the price of rent. However, this isn’t always true. If you don’t have a high enough credit score to secure a reasonable rate, your potential mortgage may cost just as much as your rent.
It’s also important to note that while mortgage payments can be lower than rent payments, your mortgage is only one of the many ongoing expenses of homeownership. After you make your down payment, you’ll still be responsible for property taxes, insurance and maintenance costs.
Equity
You may have heard people say that when you pay rent instead of a mortgage, you’re “throwing away” money every month. While that’s not exactly true, these people are usually referring to the fact that a mortgage allows you to build equity. This is a major advantage of buying a home as opposed to renting.
In the context of buying a home, equity is the percentage of your home that you own. When you make a down payment or a mortgage payment, you’re building equity. The more equity you have, the closer your home is to being paid off.
However, having equity is useful even if your home isn’t paid off yet. When you have enough equity, you can borrow against it. Home equity loans and home equity lines of credit (HELOCs) are common examples.
Flexibility
Even if they hope to one day own a home, many people rent because they think they may need to relocate. If you need the flexibility to easily move for a new job, renting may be the better option.
Property Taxes
When you own a home, you’re responsible for paying property taxes. These taxes are based on a home’s appraised value, so they usually increase each year.
Property taxes are typically around 1% of a home’s current value, but you may be able to take advantage of deductions and credits to lower your effective tax rate.
Tax Benefits
Sometimes, owning a home comes with tax benefits. However, you can usually only secure these advantages if you itemize deductions (as opposed to claiming the standard deduction). If you choose to itemize deductions, you should be able to deduct mortgage interest and property taxes.
Maintenance And Repairs
Although the cost of rent often exceeds what you’d pay for a mortgage, that cost includes maintenance and repairs. As a renter, you don’t have to worry about footing the bill for a new furnace or repairing a hole in the roof after a storm. When you own your home, you alone are responsible for ongoing maintenance costs.
What’s Your Goal?
Buy A Home
Discover mortgage options that fit your unique financial needs.
Refinance
Refinance your mortgage to have more money for what matters.
Tap Into Equity
Use your home’s equity and unlock cash to achieve your goals.
Rent Vs. Buy: Pros And Cons
When comparing buying with renting, neither option is clearly better than the other. Each has its benefits and drawbacks, and you should carefully weigh them all before making a decision.
The Pros and Cons Of Buying A House
Here’s a quick overview of the main benefits and drawbacks of buying a house:
The Pros and Cons Of Buying A House
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| The opportunity to build valuable equity | The potential for high upfront costs |
| Improvements to credit score | The possibility of selling for less if home values drop |
| Full control over renovations and upgrades | Financial responsibility for renovations or maintenance |
| Tax benefits | Extra expenses beyond a mortgage payment |
Owning a home means having more freedom but also greater financial responsibility. Because most mortgages have fixed monthly payments, you won’t have to worry about annual price increases like you would with rent.
You can also take advantage of another key benefit: the ability to use the home for rental income. Most landlords don’t allow subletting, but when you’re the property owner, you can generate extra income by renting out a room or the whole house.
That said, it’s important to note that securing financing for a home may be difficult depending on your financial situation. If you don’t meet the buyer qualifications most lenders set, you may qualify only for a high-interest mortgage (or no mortgage at all).
The Pros and Cons Of Renting
Here’s a look at some of the major benefits and drawbacks of renting:
The Pros and Cons Of Renting
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Consistent monthly payments | No equity is being built. |
| No down payment or closing costs | Possible rent increases from landlords |
| The landlord is responsible for repairs and maintenance. | More restrictions on the use of space, upgrades, renovations and pets |
| Flexibility to move once the lease ends | No tax benefits |
While rent payments can often be more expensive than mortgage payments, they can be much cheaper in some housing markets. However, even if your rent is greater than a normal mortgage payment, renting a home still presents certain financial advantages.
You don’t have to make a down payment or cover closing costs, and you also won’t need to worry about paying for expensive repairs. The trade-off is that landlords generally increase rent each year, so you may not have as much freedom as you would if you owned your home.
While many landlords check credit scores, it’s often easier to get approved for a lease than a mortgage. If you don’t have everything needed to buy a house (like a solid credit score and a reasonable debt-to-income ratio), there’s nothing wrong with renting for the time being.
Ready To Become A Homeowner?
Get matched with a lender that can help you find the right mortgage.
What Factors Should You Consider When Deciding To Rent Or Buy?
Trying to decide between buying and renting can be challenging. Each option has its share of advantages and disadvantages, and what’s right for one person may not be right for another. If you’re not sure where to begin, consider these important factors:
Home Prices And Rent Vary
If you’re hoping to buy a house, you should know that mortgage rates aren’t the only factor that influences pricing. Housing supply and affordability vary considerably depending on the local market. For example, in a high-priced market like San Francisco, renting may be the only viable option.
Buying Ties You To One Place
If you know you’ve found where you want to live for the foreseeable future, buying a home may be the next logical step. However, if you think you may want to relocate before long, renting gives you the flexibility to do so.
Homeowners Are Responsible For Maintenance And Taxes
Renters generally aren’t authorized to customize their homes. While homeowners enjoy more freedom, they’re also responsible for handling routine maintenance and repairs. When you rent a home, the landlord is responsible for repairs and most types of ongoing maintenance.
Buying Comes With Significant Upfront Costs
While mortgage payments are often lower than rent payments, purchasing a house involves significant upfront and ongoing costs. When you buy a home, you must generally make a down payment plus pay closing costs, which are typically 2% – 6% of the sale price.
Some new home buyers don’t realize that they’ll have routine ongoing costs as well. You’ll definitely need homeowners insurance and may need mortgage insurance as well, and you’ll be responsible for paying property taxes. And if your home is in an area with a homeowners association (HOA), you may have to pay HOA dues.
Buying Builds Equity
Although buying a home requires a long-term commitment, that commitment pays off in the form of equity. Because home values generally appreciate over time, building equity in your home is a worthwhile investment.
Take The First Step To Buying A Home
Find a lender that will work with your unique financial situation.
FAQ About Buying Vs. Renting A Home
The decision between renting and buying a home is a significant one that shouldn’t be taken lightly. With numerous factors to consider, it’s crucial to address some commonly asked questions regarding this choice.
If you’re in the early stages of your career, starting with renting can be advantageous as you work to earn promotions and build good credit. As your career progresses, your increased income and a strong credit score can pave the way for an affordable mortgage with favorable terms.
Notably, renting can be cheaper if you invest your savings wisely. When you buy a home, you pay a significant amount up front but get a substantial return on investment. To see a similar return as a renter, you would need to take the equivalent of a mortgage payment each month and invest it in a high-yield savings account.
If the annual costs are higher than 5%, renting might be a more economical choice, as it offers flexibility and avoids the substantial financial commitment associated with homeownership. Ultimately, the 5% rule is a helpful guideline for individuals considering the financial implications of the renting-versus-buying decision. It’s wise to chat with a financial advisor when making financial decisions.
Additionally, owning a home involves ongoing costs, such as maintenance, property taxes and interest on the mortgage, which can impact the overall financial outcome. Ultimately, the decision to buy a home should align with one’s long-term financial goals and lifestyle preferences.
Rent-to-own can be advantageous if you require extra time to amass a down payment or enhance your credit score prior to homeownership. Nonetheless, it’s crucial to meticulously examine the contract’s terms, encompassing the purchase cost, the duration of the rental period and any supplementary charges, to verify that it harmonizes with your overarching financial strategy.
The Bottom Line
Both renting and buying come with unique benefits that cater to your specific objectives and way of life. Renting may seem like an expense without returns, but it can be a practical choice when you’re focused on growing your savings and credit score or anticipating a relocation.
Conversely, homeownership becomes more appealing when you’re planning to establish long-term roots in your community, extending beyond a five-year horizon and aiming to build equity in a property.
Sarah Edwards
Sarah Edwards is passionate about financial literacy and helping readers overcome their money challenges. She has a talent for breaking down complex financial topics into clear, accessible language that resonates with everyday audiences. Her work regularly covers personal finance, law, real estate and small business. Sarah’s bylines have appeared in publications including Forbes, NerdWallet, Benzinga, and MoneyLion.
